John Jordan
- 1953 – beat Eastern Kentucky 72-57; beat Pennsylvania 69-57; lost to Indiana 79-66.
- 1954 – beat Loyola, La. 80-70; beat Indiana 65-64; lost to Penn State 71-63.
- 1957 – beat Miami (Ohio) 89-77; lost to Michigan State 85-83; beat Pittsburgh 86-85.
- 1958 – beat Tennessee Tech 94-61; beat Indiana 94-87; lost to Kentucky 89-56.
- 1960 – lost to Ohio 74-66.
- 1963 – lost to Bowling Green 77-72.
Johnny Dee
- 1965 – lost to Houston 99-98.
- 1969 – lost to Miami (Ohio) 63-60.
- 1970 – beat Ohio 112-82; lost to Kentucky 109-99; lost to Iowa 121-106.
- 1971 – beat Texas Christian 102-94; lost to Drake 79-72, OT; lost to Houston 119-106.
Digger Phelps
- 1974 – beat Austin Peay 108-66; lost to Michigan 77-68; beat Vanderbilt 118-88.
- 1975 – beat Kansas 77-71; lost to Maryland 83-71; lost to Cincinnati 95-87, OT.
- 1976 – beat Cincinnati 79-78; lost to Michigan 80-76.
- 1977 – beat Hofstra 90-83; lost to North Carolina 79-77.
- 1978 – beat Houston 100-77; beat Utah 69-56; beat DePaul 84-64; lost to Duke 90-86; lost to Arkansas 71-69. Final Four.
- 1979 – beat Tennessee 73-67; beat Toledo 79-71; lost to Michigan State 80-68.
- 1980 – lost to Missouri 87-84, OT.
- 1981 – beat James Madison 54-45; lost to Brigham Young 51-50.
- 1985 – beat Oregon State 79-70; lost to North Carolina 60-58.
- 1986 – lost to North Carolina State 66-64.
- 1987 – beat Middle Tennessee State 84-71; beat Texas Christian 58-57; lost to North Carolina 74-68.
- 1988 – lost to Southern Methodist 83-75.
- 1989 – beat Vanderbilt 81-65; lost to Georgetown 81-74.
- 1990 – lost to Virginia 75-67.
Mike Brey