A total of 10 Notre Dame student-athletes have earned CoSIDA Academic All-America recognition on three occasions during their Fighting Irish careers, including a trio of three-time first-team CoSIDA Academic All-Americans, and two Academic All-Americans of the Year. The following list includes all of Notre Dame’s three-time Academic All-Americans across all teams and all sports, dating back to the inception of the CoSIDA Academic All-America program in 1952.
 |  |  |
| Tom Gibbons Football | Jarrah Myers Softball | Joe Heap Football |
 |  |  |
| John Loughran Baseball | Vanessa Pruzinsky Women's Soccer | Bob Arnzen Men's Basketball |
 |  |  |
| Erika Bohn Women's Soccer | Joy Battersby Softball | Katie Marten Softball |
 | ||
| Greg Dingens Football |
| CHRONOLOGICAL LISTING | |||
| Name | 1stYr/Sport/Tm/Pos | 2ndYr/Sport/Tm/Pos | 3rdYr/Sport/Tm/Pos |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Heap | 1952/Football/1st/RB | 1953/Football/1st/RB | 1954/Football/1st/RB |
| Bob Arnzen | 1967/M Basketball/1st/F | 1968/M Basketball/1st/F | 1969/M Basketball/1st/F |
| Tom Gibbons | 1978/Football/2nd/DB | 1979/Football/2nd/DB | 1980/Football/1st/DB |
| Greg Dingens | 1983/Football/2nd/DL | 1984/Football/1st/DL | 1985/Football/1st/DL |
| John Loughran | 1985/Baseball/3rd/OF | 1986/Baseball/1st/OF | 1987/Baseball/2nd/OF |
| Joy Battersby | 1995/Softball/2nd/P | 1996/Softball/2nd/P | 1997/Softball/3rd/P |
| Katie Marten | 1995/Softball/3rd/DH | 1996/Softball/2nd/DH | 1997/Softball/1st/DH |
| Jarrah Myers# | 2000/Softball/3rd/C | 2001/Softball/1st/C | 2002/Softball/1st/C |
| Vanessa Pruzinsky# | 2000/W At-Large/1st/D | 2001/W At-Large/1st/D | 2003/W Soccer/1st/D |
| Erika Bohn | 2003/W Soccer/2nd/G | 2004/W Soccer/1st/G | 2005/W Soccer/1st/G |
| Ashley Armstrong | 2013/W At-Large/3rd | 2014/W At-Large/2nd | 2015/W At-Large/2nd |
| # – Academic All-America Team Member Of The Year | |||
|
|
|||
| THREE-TIME FIRST-TEAM ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS | |||
| Joe Heap | 1952/Football/RB | 1953/Football/RB | 1954/Football/RB |
| Bob Arnzen | 1967/M Basketball/F | 1968/M Basketball/F | 1969/M Basketball/F |
| Vanessa Pruzinsky# | 2001/W At-Large/D | 2002/W At-Large/Soccer | 2003/W Soccer/D |
| # – Academic All-America Team Member Of The Year | |||
|
|
|||
| BASEBALL THREE-TIME ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS (1) | |||
| John Loughran | 1985/3rd/OF | 1986/1st/OF | 1987/2nd/OF |
|
|
|||
| MEN’S BASKETBALL THREE-TIME ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS (1) | |||
| Bob Arnzen | 1967/1st/F | 1968/1st/F | 1969/1st/F |
|
|
|||
| FOOTBALL THREE-TIME ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS (3) | |||
| Joe Heap | 1952/1st/RB | 1953/1st/RB | 1954/1st/RB |
| Tom Gibbons | 1978/2nd/DB | 1979/2nd/DB | 1980/1st/DB |
| Greg Dingens | 1983/2nd/DL | 1984/1st/DL | 1985/1st/DL |
|
|
|||
| Women’s Golf Three-Time Academic All-Americans (1) | |||
| Ashley Armstrong | 2013/W At-Large/3rd | 2014/W At-Large/2nd | 2015/W At-Large/2nd |
|
|
|||
| WOMEN’S SOCCER THREE-TIME ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS (2) | |||
| Vanessa Pruzinsky# | 2001/1st/W At-Large | 2002/1st/W At-Large | 2003/1st/D |
| Erika Bohn | 2003/2nd/G | 2004/1st/G | 2005/1st/G |
| # – Academic All-America Team Member Of The Year | |||
|
|
|||
| SOFTBALL THREE-TIME ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS (3) | |||
| Joy Battersby | 1995/2nd/P | 1996/2nd/P | 1997/3rd/P |
| Katie Marten | 1995/3rd/DH | 1996/2nd/DH | 1997/1st/DH |
| Jarrah Myers# | 2000/3rd/C | 2001/1st/C | 2002/1st/C |